Should college athletes be paid essay 924 words bartleby. Paying college athletes has been a trending topic around the national collegiate athletic association over the years. Obviously not all student athletes qualify as professionals, but if they do, why cant we pay them. Everything they wear brings profit to companies that have paid to turn. Ncaa sites prison labor to justify not paying studentathletes.
Top 10 reasons college athletes should not be paid top. The truth is, the only collegiate sports that really make anything for the colleges are football and basketball, and only the top championship teams really bring in money for their schools. Student athletes should not be paid at state university, because it focuses on an extracurricular activity as a means of profit, praises athletic ability over merit scholastics, promotes a bridge between players and regular students, and creates hierarchy between universities. I believe that student athletes should be monetarily compensated for their work. Paying college athletes would create a whole new playing field, and the consequences would be costly march madness free, not punfree. College athletes should not be paid in order to keep a clear divide between amateur and professional sports. As the ncaa president said, this approach would mean a fundamental change. Athletes should receive a monthly stipend for living expenses, insurance coverage, and paid trips home during holidays and for family emergencies. Larger schools with more money would be able to buy out better players. In short, these are revenueproducing paid athletes first, and students only incidentally.
However, there are just as many athletes who do not play with these similarities. Jan 20, 2012 the hours athletes put in eliminate any semblance of college life. Students are not professional athletes who are paid salaries and. To what extent should college athletes be paid or not. How everyone is getting rich off college sports except the players. College athletes ask for pay in sports and want to know why they are not getting paid.
Many people will say that college athletes should get paid because they think that all the money the athletic program receives goes to a bunch of guys in suits like a. Not just for those whose careers end prematurely because of injury but for all athletes accepting the participation risks. College athletes should not be paid sports and athletes, 2005 as you read, consider the following questions. What claim did webber make during his college years about how little money he had, as paraphrased by whitlock.
On top of a free ride the school should pay them, as well. College athletes should not be paid money complications college is a ton of money most college athletic programs spend more than they make 2012. Student athletes should not be paid more than any other student at. College athletes already have advantages and shouldnt be paid. The bureau of labor statistics and the united states department of labor reports there are,800 professional athletes in the u. The purpose of going to college is to get training and knowledge for a career that you will pursue in your future. Thats what the national collegiate athlete association provides. Oct 28, 2016 college athletes should not be paid to play any sports when they are in college. Essay why college athletes shouldnt get paid 906 words. Shortly following napiers comment about going to bed. No, our countries in debt and our colleges are barely making. The truth is, the only collegiate sports that really make anything for the colleges are football and basketball, and only the top championship teams really bring in. Since these players are in college, they should never be paid to play their sport.
Ncaa studentathletes is the decision of who will be getting paid. Many people believe athletes should get paid for their hard work, while others believe that it would ruin the integrity of college sports if athletes were paid. The livers case argues that studentathletes who get scholarships should at least be paid as workstudy students for the time they put in. Pay the players adequately for the services they provide on the field. Paying college athletes would be unnecessary, unfair, and unfeasible. Despite the strength of the reasons as to why studentathletes should not be paid, there are certain problems with the current ncaa system which can and should be cured. Among ncaa student athletes, 15 percent say they wouldnt even be in college if they didnt play a sport. Paying a few of them more will not improve college sports. March madness means a huge payday for coaches, colleges, networks and advertisers everyone except the athletes themselves. Facilitating education for athletes despite the strength of the reasons as to why student athletes should not be paid, there are certain problems with the current ncaa system which can and should be cured.
From my standpoint, we cannot do enough for these student athletes medically. The argument is that since such institutions receive millions of dollars from the performance, the studentathletes should be paid. Although the full athletic scholarships that many college athletes enjoy should not be overlooked, it also should be noted that the education the students receive is not a form of currency. Many college coaches are the highest paid public employees in their statesa five. College athletes are people that are trying to get to the pros and therefore, are not paid because they have not made it yet. So maybe its not such an irrational statement to claim that some college athletes are professionals. Now, however, that billions of dollars are flowing to amateur athletics, a more basic american tradition is appropriate to consider. Those who say college studentathletes should not be paid argue that they receive scholarships as a form of payment for their talents. Why the ncaa shouldnt pay athletes swimswam welcomes reader submissions about all topics aquatic, and if its wellwritten and wellthought, we might just post it under. Should college athletes be paid download ebook pdf, epub. Parents should be able to take plane tickets and hotel rooms to see their kids play, without fear of ncaa blowback. The hours athletes put in eliminate any semblance of college life.
Many have strong opinions about this topic, and the opinions vary. Mar 26, 2014 the vast majority of college basketball players never make it to the prosunder 100 out of about 5,000 athletesand an allexpenses paid degree provides a much better incentive than a paycheck. College athletes should not be paid by timara marie on prezi. Aug 29, 20 student athletes are already paid and the current system is pretty close to as fair as we are going to get. Apr 26, 2016 it is also part of the argument to pay college athletes more. The discussion of paying college athletes began in 1991 when the famed fab five became a. These athletes collectively generate tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars annually for their schools. Essay on student athletes should not be paid 941 words. Recently, the ncaa has made some changes it says are intended to bolster the success of studentathletes on the playing field, in the classroom and in life after college. College athletes should not be paid the badger herald. A plan for compensating studentathletes byu law digital. Jan 06, 2014 the argument is that since such institutions receive millions of dollars from the performance, the student athletes should be paid. This article would not have been possible without the work of.
In the second paragraph he writes that there is no system of payment that can be put in place that is fair across the board to all students, all sports and all schools that participate in college athletics. When the national collegiate athletic association ncaa was founded by president roosevelt in 1906, there was a commitment that a salary would not be provided to the student athletes. College athletes dont get paid because theyre not adults. There have been convincing facts from both sides on whether these college athletes should receive pay while in school performing at their specific athletic event. A small fraction of players, the ones destined for fame. Ncaas oliver luck on why theres an open market for coaches pay and not athletes. Top 10 reasons college athletes should not be paid collegiate sports are big money makers, at least thats what most people think, right. Facilitating education for athletes despite the strength of the reasons as to why studentathletes should not be paid, there are certain problems with the current ncaa system which can and should be cured. Request pdf athlete pay and competitive balance in college. Experience through the ncaa goals and score studies. My first point is scholarships come with many benefits. College sports are big business, and students should reap the benefits for all the hard work and talent they bring to the table.
This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. May 24, 2016 paying college athletes would be unnecessary, unfair, and unfeasible. In a significant ruling from ed obannon case, an appeals court upheld a decision that ncaa rules violated antitrust laws but did vacate an injunction allowing. What it ultimately boils down to is the transition of college athletics being driven primarily. Student athletes are already paid and the current system is pretty close to as fair as we are going to get. Connecticut debate association january 7, 2012, fairfield. Paying college athletes wont solve the big problem with us college sports. What the ncaa did in response to the lawsuit is as vile. Athletes by ron katz, issac vaughn, and mike gilleran 1. There are several objections to the argument of paying college athletes, and the common ones are as follows. How do many college athletes allow themselves to be exploited, in whitlocks opinion. See lee goldman, sports and antitrust should college students be paid to play. After looking through more articles i have concluded that they should not be paid because its there own choice to participate.
College athletes should be paid, its as simple as that. The shame of college sports by taylor branch, the atlantic, october 2011 the united states is the only country in the world that hosts bigtime sports at institutions of higher learning. The continued exploitation of the college athlete core. These students are, essentially, employees for a billiondollar business, but they dont get paid. Court shuts down plan to pay athletes, says ncaa violates. Top 10 reasons why college athletes should not be paid aws. According to the ncaa, as of 2014, there are 450,000 studentathletes that compete across all sports. Dear next president, ive seen a lot of articles and sometimes even heard about why college athletes should be paid for their work and spending big amounts of hour to practice. Rules stating that a player cant be paid are outdated and have no standing with how todays college athlete is treated and how many responsibilities they have to their given universities. Using your sub points to develop your essay should give you an interesting and truthful essay. I feel that your essay will show your true opinion on.
The financial implications of paying college athletes by. Dec 05, 2016 most college athletes get their college paid for on a scholarship. The ncaa will begin to lose more athletes to professional athletics early, which. T he time commitments, revenues, and physical risks that millions of other student athletes play with can all be comparable to those found on a professional level. This should not, in and of itself, be controversial. The question of if college athletes should get paid or not is a very large debate in the sports community right now. For years now there have been the argument if college athletes should be paid to play or not. College athletes say they need pay al jazeera america. It is an ongoing debate between many people including the national collegiate athletic associationncaa, athletes, coach, and other various people. Student athletes are not employees, they shouldnt get paid to play. Student athletes should not get paid because they receive beneficial scholarships, they sign the national letter of intent, and they are a student before they are an athlete.
Student athletes should not be paid in the world of college athletics there are endless topics discussed daily and most pertain to money. Other pending legal challenges seek to test ncaa policies that strictly limit the amount of money that studentathletes can receive while playing. Arguments against paying athletes should manziel get paid. However, these student athletes must fit into specific categories regarding revenues, time commitments, and injury risks.
It would leave other schools with not many good players and they wouldnt stand a chance. Athletes shouldnt be paid, paying student athletes erodes that association. A big reason college athletes should not be paid is simply because they are not professionals. This information certainly supports the fact that college athletes should be paid, but there is a lot more to the debate than this. Feb 26, 2014 scoop jacksons article the myth of parity claims that college athletes should not get paid. There are plenty of others in the same situation that wouldnt be getting compensated for their lack of a job, so this argument does not make sense.
It is also part of the argument to pay college athletes more. College athletes should not be paid because it ruins the way that college players pick which colleges to go to. Why college athletes should not be paid essay sample. This is where perspective should enter the discussion. However, college athletes are not professionals and therefore should not be paid.
The gap between a full scholarship and the cost of attendance should be covered by the academic institution, especially when a student athlete does not qualify for a loan. The financial gap between athletic scholarships and athlete. Media basketball commentator dick vitale suggests a modest plan to make the system somewhat fairer. Nov 25, 2015 while there are reasons not to pay the athletes, there is a farther greater problem and a greater variety of issues regarding the insufficient compensation paid to the athletes from the ncaa. Click download or read online button to get should college athletes be paid book now. These students train all year round and eat, breathe, live and sleep the sport.
In 2006, division i further segmented football into the football. The book was very informative and gave him many quotes for his paper. Outline college athletes being paid college athletes. Student athletes should not get paid by their schools the daily aztec. First, the profitmaximizing goal is not usually realistic, because athletic. Athlete pay and competitive balance in college athletics request. All in all, i stand firm on my opinion that college athletes should be paid primarily in scholarship money but receive a small salary relative to the specific sports net income. Most college athletes get their college paid for on a scholarship. College athletes should be paid competitive salaries. Top 10 reasons college athletes should not be paid top 10. Student athletes should not be paid essay 1778 words cram. The service that college athletes provide to the institutions they attend in addition to millions of spectators all over the world is still not being rewarded in the. While there are reasons not to pay the athletes, there is a farther greater problem and a greater variety of issues regarding the insufficient compensation paid to the athletes from the ncaa. Basketball and football are just two of the sports for which students are asking to get paid.
The concept of amateurism can and should be reassessed so that it does not become obsolete in light of changed circumstances, such as the amount of money generated by some college sports and the level of commitment many of todays studentathletes must make in order to succeed. This book was purchased for my son who is researching for his term paper of the same title as this book. Such a policy will go a long way in ensuring that student. An issue that falls under this category includes the heated debate involving whether or not student athletes should receive money. Ncaas nopay rules violate section 1 of the sherman act, 64 case w. Mar, 2017 after all, of the more than 480,000 ncaa student athletes playing today, fewer than 2 percent will become professional athletes. College athletes should not be paid to play any sports when they are in college.
For one thing, it would come close to destroying the notion somewhat romantic in the modern world of bigtime, hugerevenue college sports that athletes are there for. I will argue that college athletes should not get paid. Catalano 1 matthew catalano instructor ryan enc 1102 11 february 2017 finding common ground. But it is the miscellaneous expenses like new shoes that have put him and other players in the center of the debate going on at the ncaa convention this week in. College athletes in major universities dont pay for transportation, tuition or team facilities. Because of all these reasons, the argument that the athletes in big sports football, basketball should be paid on basis of the fact that they cannot get a job does not hold any weight.
1206 670 641 1074 748 259 499 1497 898 846 1328 236 595 743 1300 391 404 136 1384 389 1348 559 658 62 31 1350 1465 823 134 154 761 1365 188 529 592